Are NED memories under hypnosis valid?

*NOTE: I’m not a huge fan of hypnotic memory recall, but I found an article online that seemed interesting so I wanted to share some info about it. Please don’t contact asking if I do this type of work as I do not at this time.*

A question on whether a near-death experience (NED) are perceptions of reality or the hallucinations of dying men or not, has not gone unnoticed in scientific researches, particularly neuroscience and phenomenology. The nature of NEDs is largely unappreciated; however, recent studies have shown intriguing possibility that the condition involves “actual perception and storage of experiences to either the internal or external physical world”. It implies that NEDs are the life-changing experiences that occur in people who have experienced a physiological or psychological closeness to death such as the case of cardiac arrest or accidents, respectively. Notably, after being close to death, most people report to have experienced an external (out-of-body) experience, accounts on how they passed through a tunnel, or having seen a strange bright light throughout the ordeal. Scientifically, NEDs are the profound psychological events characterized by mystical and transcendental elements, which occur to persons close to death, emotional danger or in a situation of intense emotional or physical danger (Greyson, 2015). In an attempt to appreciate the after-effects of the NEDs, there have been attempts to enhance remembrance of things, events and situations during the NEDs through hypnotic recall and flashbacks (Facco, 2012; Lynn et al., 1997), albeit with varied levels of success. In order to appreciate the whole issues on NED and hypnotic recall, neurophenomenology has therefore focused on investigating and addressing the hard questions of the whole idea of consciousness in a practical way, combining both phenomenology and neuroscience.

Martial et al. (2019), upon identifying the gaps in literature, particularly on the neurobiological basis of NED under laboratory conditions, used a state-of-art brain monitoring high-density electroencephalography (EEG) to explore the brain activity as the basis of the NDE recall and the neurophenomenological approach to assess the phenomenological experiences of subjective first-person experiencers. Five volunteers (mean age 57 ±11 years) with previous experiences of a pleasant NDE were recruited in their study and invited to re-experience the NED memory as well as other pleasant autobiography memory, in normal consciousness and with hypnosis. A comparison was made between the hypnosis-induced subjective experiences with one of the experience memory considered to be the genuine ones, while recording the high-density EEG throughout the study. Martial et al. (2019) managed to recreate NDE-like features without any negative effects. Moreover, they established that the absorption and dissociation levels were higher with all the hypnosis conditions in comparison to the normal consciousness situations. This finding suggested that Martial et al. (2019) managed to increase the felt subjective experience with the hypnosis-based protocol in the recall of the normal consciousness and during the hypnosis conditions. Importantly, the researchers concluded that the recall of NDE phenomenology is linked to the increase of alpha activity in the posterior and frontal regions at the scalp level. Thus, Martial et al. (2019) provides a proof-of-concept methodology for the study and appreciation of hypnotic recall and near-death experience memory, which also provides the foundation for the prospective exploration of the NDE-like features as well as the associated EEG changes under laboratory settings.

Other researchers have also attempted to provide various approaches in the study of hypnotic recall and near-death experience memory in different settings. Palmieri et al. (2014) provide evidences on the reality of NDE memories using an integrated study of both psychodynamic and electrophysiological approaches. The integrated approach was adopted as an improved protocol that included a hypnosis-based clinical protocol to decrease inaccuracies in memory and improves recall, together with EEG recording; thus, help in investigating the nature of NDE memories and the neural markers involved in comparison with the memories of imagined and real situations. Using a sample size of 10 people with NDEs and 10 control subjects, and through a Memory Characteristic Questionnaire, the researchers found similarities between the real memories and NDE memories in terms of emotional information, self-referential and detail richness. Otherwise, results from EEG indicated a positive association between real memory and two memory-related frequency bands (gamma and alpha), with the recall of NDE related to delta band. In conclusion, at a phenomenological level, there is no equivalence between NDE memories and imagined memories, whereas at the neural level, episodic memories of situations and events stores the NDE memories, which are experienced at an unusual state of consciousness.

In summary, EEG, there is enough evidence that NDE memories are different from what is considered as imagined autobiographical memories; however, they are similar to the real-event memories. Such similarities are based on the self-referential, detail richness and emotional information. Notably, the incorporation of EEG provides the basis for an improved approach in recording hypnotic recall, which is an important step in the facilitation of memory retrieval. Thus, the studies contribute to further step in an attempt to appreciating the NDE memories under controlled settings.

References

Greyson, B. (2015). Near-Death Experiencers. Death Anxiety Handbook: Research, Instrumentation, And Application, 169.

Lynn, S., Lock, T., Myers, B., & Payne, D. (1997). Recalling the Unrecallable: Should Hypnosis Be Used to Recover Memories in Psychotherapy? Current Directions in Psychological Science,6(3), 79-83.

Facco, E. (2012). Near-death experiences and hypnosis: Two different phenomena with something in common. Contemporary Hypnosis & Integrative Therapy, 29(3).

Martial, C., Mensen, A., Charland-Verville, V., Vanhaudenhuyse, A., Rentmeister, D., Bahri, M. A., & Faymonville, M. E. (2019). Neurophenomenology of near-death experience memory in hypnotic recall: a within-subject EEG study. Scientific reports, 9(1), 1-11.

Palmieri, A., Calvo, V., Kleinbub, J. R., Meconi, F., Marangoni, M., Barilaro, P., & Sessa, P. (2014). “Reality” of near-death-experience memories: evidence from a psychodynamic and electrophysiological integrated study. Frontiers in human neuroscience, 8, 429.

Melvin S. Marsh is a certified life coach and hypnotherapist serving Atlanta GA, Augusta GA, Statesboro GA, and Savannah GA. He performs hypnotherapy and life coaching appointments both in person and worldwide virtually. He can be reached at www.afterhourshypnotherapy.com .