Hypnosis, Neuroscience, and Pain Perception

Studies have shown individuals with high and low scores of hypnotizability show differences involving the “morpho-functional characteristics of the cerebral and cerebellar cortex, cardiovascular control, and sensorimotor integration”. Research has also shown the highs and lows to portray cognitive differences in imagery abilities, attention, and in the functional equivalence between imagery and perception. One of the highly researched hypnotizability-related differences is the individuals’ ability to control pain when exposed to suggestions targeting various pain dimensions. However, physiological and psychosocial differences between highs and lows in terms of pain control in the absence of hypnotic suggestions have not been reported except for a few studies that have used controlled experiments.

It has been determined that pain perception and pain imagery both share the same neural circuits. Studies have found a strong functional equivalence between perception and nociceptive imagery in the highs at the behavioral and cortical levels. Researchers conclude that this finding may be indicating that highs are more likely than lows to develop chronic pain.

This is an indication that highs and lows have different mechanisms of pain control. Studies have also explored how hypnotizability affects the interference of cued and non-cued nociceptive stimulation of the supraorbital nerve. Theoretically, it is expected that visual cues may induce expectations that can decrease pain perception by triggering anticipatory pain control mechanisms. However, this effect may also increase pain perception since the visual cue may also trigger pain-related mental imagery, which is a characteristic usually observed among the highs than the lows (Seyedeh-Parisa Zarei et al., 2020).

The findings of a study by Seyedeh-Parisa Zarei et al. (2020) were similar with those of earlier researches that showed connections between pain-related contralateral central nodes and the ipsilateral central region. The frontal areas of the brain influence pain-associated areas, and this influence is related to cognitive aspects of pain processing. The findings of the study indicate that pain-related visual representations are suppressed in highs, which may be interpreted as a mechanism of coping with incoming stimulation.

This phenomenon is not observed in the lows who portray a detachment strategy. These findings show hypnotizability related-differences in pain expectation between the highs and the lows, which point to differences in pain-related traits among individuals. According to these findings, highs are likely to be less vulnerable than lows to pain induced changes of their global experience.

A study by Perri et al. (2020) found that hypnotic effects lead to a reduced engagement of the neural network composing of anterior insula, thalamacortical radiations, and cingulate gyrus. Hypnosis reduced pre-stimulus activities of the brain. It shows that hypnosis may produce relevant changes in the brain activity. It was found that the anterior part of the brain is significantly involved in the hypnotic experience, and decreased activity is always observed in parietal somatosensory associative cortex.

The researchers argue that hypnotic-guided metacognitive control might lead to the changes observed in the activities of the brain areas concerned with specific type of processing. These studies show  hypnosis has the capacity to regulate thermal and pain thresholds. They show that hypnosis led to enhanced metacognitive control and cognitive flexibility.

References

Seyedeh-Parisa Zarei , Lucia Briscese , Simone Capitani , Bruno Rossi , Maria C. Carboncini , Enrica L. Santarcangelo & Ali Motie Nasrabadi (2020): Hypnotizability-Related Effects of Pain Expectation on the Later Modulation of Cortical Connectivity, International Journal of Clinical and Experimental Hypnosis, DOI: 10.1080/00207144.2020.1762196

Perri, R. L., Facco, E., Quinzi, F., Bianco, V., Berchicci, M., Rossani, F., & Di Russo, F. (2020) Cerebral mechanisms of hypnotic hypoesthesia. An ERP investigation on the expectancy stage of perception. Psychophysiology, e13657.

Melvin S. Marsh is a certified hypnotherapist serving Atlanta GA, Augusta GA, Statesboro GA, and Savannah GA. He performs hypnotherapy appointments both in person (although that is on hold due to covid) and worldwide virtually. He can be reached at www.afterhourshypnotherapy.com .