Three types of hypnotic suggestions have been identified by researchers. These include motor, cognitive, and challenge suggestions. In motor suggestions, the therapist takes the subject through an imaginative process through which they try to imagine that something, like hand movement, will happen by itself. Challenge suggestions involve the subject being asked to imagine that some type of movement, like bending the arm, is not possible. Lastly, the cognitive type involves a situation whereby the therapist asks the subject to imagine some perceptual events (hallucination suggestion), or to try and forget some lessons learnt through a hypnotic process (amnesia suggestion). Motor suggestions can be used to alter the sense of agency (SoA), where individuals often report experiencing passivity when it comes to undertaking certain actions. However, it is argued that other neurological and psychiatric conditions can as well produce SoA alterations as opposed to hypnosis alone. Various models have been used to explain SoA alterations in schizophrenia, for example, based on predictive view of the brain or the mind, or coding in short.
Martin & Pacherie (2019) used this predictive coding method to propose a theoretical model of motor suggestions. They explain predictive coding as a model that sees the brain as an inference machine. The brain works through perception by making inferences. Through this mechanism, the brain is able to make predictions about the information being received, and this is based on the stored beliefs about the physical world. In situations where the brain makes a prediction error, the beliefs on which those predictions were made are updated so that they can be used in making future predictions. Various perception models have proposed that these kinds of inferential processes should resemble Bayesian inferences, which bases these predictions on probability distributions.
In motor suggestions, the therapist takes his or her subject through the process of imagining that a certain movement will happen on its own, which in this case is arm levitation. It is a hypnotic process in which the hypnotist makes the subject to believe that the arm will rise by itself. Motor suggestions are believed to have three features: a) It is argued that motor suggestions can elicit movements in a good number of subjects, b) the movements generated by these suggestions are always hesitant and slow, c) the suggestions temporarily alter the SoA, with a good proportion of individuals indicating that they experience passivity when it comes to carrying out their suggested actions. These three aspects raise three fundamental questions that researchers feel obliged to answer by giving an account of how hypnosis works. People may ask why hypnotic subjects respond to motor suggestions, why movements are always dysfluent, and why alterations of the SoA are elicited by certain types of motor suggestions.
It is hypothesized that the proposed predictive coding model can best account for these three features of motor suggestions. With this model, Martin & Pacherie (2019, p.137) maintain that hypnotic suggestions are characterized by: “(a) an increase in the precision of kinaesthetic and proprioceptive signals, (b) an increase in the precision of predictions regarding movement, (c) a corresponding increase in the precision of prediction errors, and (d) the provision of a highly accessible explanation for these prediction errors in terms of the operation of an external force.” It is proposed that the features of suggested motor behavior are accounted for by the increase in the predictions and in the precision of sensory input. Moreover, the researchers propose that the experience of passivity during motor suggestions can be explained by increased precision of prediction errors as well as the availability their explication. Based on the predictive model proposed, it was found that SoA alteration during hypnosis is effected by four factors, which include sensory evidence, a prior of non-agency, attention, as well as proprioceptive predictions.
References
Martin, J. R., & Pacherie, E. (2019). Alterations of agency in hypnosis: A new predictive coding model. Psychological review, 126(1), 133.
Melvin S. Marsh is a certified hypnotherapist serving Atlanta GA, Augusta GA, Statesboro GA, and Savannah GA. He performs hypnotherapy appointments both in person and worldwide virtually. He can be reached at www.afterhourshypnotherapy.com .